Analysis

Overall acceptance rate

9.42%

Average response time

1.2 months

Average publicaton time

2.6 months

Average number of reviewers

1.4

Comment quality

Submissions with comments

31.64%

Overall experience with editors

Initial Verdicts

531

Acceptances

25 (4.71%)

Rejections

471 (88.70%)

Revise and resubmits

32 (6.03%)

Conditional acceptances

3 (0.56%)

Withdraws

0 (0.00%)

Revised/conditional verdicts

Acceptances

25 (78.13%)

Rejections

6 (18.75%)

Withdraws

1 (3.13%)

	Submitted	Verdict	Professional status	Response time	Comment quality
Apr 3, 2023	Rejection	Graduate student	0.2 months	-
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 3, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 0.2 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Apr 8, 2023	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	2.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 8, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 2.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 3 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Apr 13, 2023	Rejection	Graduate student	0.6 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 13, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 0.6 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Apr 24, 2023	Rejection	Graduate student	5.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 24, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 5.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
May 11, 2023	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	0.8 months	-
Journal Analysis Submitted May 11, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 0.8 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
May 17, 2023	Revise and resubmit Acceptance	Graduate student	6.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted May 17, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Acceptance Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity Hispanic/Latina/Latino Response time 6.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter
May 30, 2023	Rejection	Graduate student	0.5 months	-	-
Journal Analysis Submitted May 30, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 0.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors - Comments from submitter
Jun 2, 2023	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	0.9 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jun 2, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 0.9 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jul 4, 2023	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	1.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jul 4, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 1.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jul 14, 2023	Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	0.8 months	-
Journal Analysis Submitted Jul 14, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity Asian Response time 0.8 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jul 25, 2023	Rejection	Graduate student	1.7 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jul 25, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Female Race/ethnicity Hispanic/Latina/Latino Response time 1.7 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Sep 15, 2023	Rejection	Other	1.2 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Sep 15, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Other Gender Male Race/ethnicity Asian Response time 1.2 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Nov 1, 2023	Rejection	Graduate student	0.2 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Nov 1, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity Asian Response time 0.2 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Nov 22, 2023	Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	1.6 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Nov 22, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 1.6 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter
Dec 6, 2023	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	1.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Dec 6, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 1.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Dec 8, 2023	Rejection	Graduate student	2 months		-
Journal Analysis Submitted Dec 8, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 2 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors - Comments from submitter
Dec 20, 2023	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	1 month	-
Journal Analysis Submitted Dec 20, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 1 month Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Dec 29, 2023	Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	1.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Dec 29, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 1.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jan 7, 2024	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	2.3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 7, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender Female Race/ethnicity White Response time 2.3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jan 10, 2024	Revise and resubmit Acceptance	Other	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 10, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Acceptance Professional status Other Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Feb 4, 2024	Rejection	Graduate student	2 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Feb 4, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 2 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Feb 9, 2024	Revise and resubmit Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Feb 9, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Feb 12, 2024	Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	0.5 months	-
Journal Analysis Submitted Feb 12, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity Indigenous North, Central or South American White Response time 0.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors Comments from submitter
Feb 23, 2024	Revise and resubmit Acceptance	Non-tenure track faculty	1 month
Journal Analysis Submitted Feb 23, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Acceptance Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 1 month Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter The production team took 8 months to typeset the paper, with errors remaining.
Mar 4, 2024	Rejection	Graduate student	2.8 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Mar 4, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity Asian Response time 2.8 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Mar 5, 2024	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	1.2 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Mar 5, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 1.2 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Mar 29, 2024	Rejection	Graduate student	1.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Mar 29, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 1.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter The comments were overall polite but of poor philosophical quality. They also contained bibliographic inaccuracies, which makes me question whether the reviewer was an expert in either of the subfields my paper discussed.
Apr 11, 2024	Rejection	Other	0.8 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 11, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Other Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 0.8 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Apr 28, 2024	Rejection	Graduate student	0.5 months	-
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 28, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity Asian Response time 0.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors Comments from submitter
May 1, 2024	Rejection	Graduate student	1.8 months
Journal Analysis Submitted May 1, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 1.8 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
May 1, 2024	Rejection	Graduate student	0.3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted May 1, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 0.3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -