Analysis

Overall acceptance rate

9.47%

Average response time

1.2 months

Average publicaton time

2.6 months

Average number of reviewers

1.4

Comment quality

Submissions with comments

31.44%

Overall experience with editors

Initial Verdicts

528

Acceptances

25 (4.73%)

Rejections

468 (88.64%)

Revise and resubmits

32 (6.06%)

Conditional acceptances

3 (0.57%)

Withdraws

0 (0.00%)

Revised/conditional verdicts

Acceptances

25 (78.13%)

Rejections

6 (18.75%)

Withdraws

1 (3.13%)

	Submitted	Verdict	Professional status	Response time	Comment quality
Mar 24, 2015	Rejection	Graduate student	75 months	-
Journal Analysis Submitted Mar 24, 2015 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity european Response time 75 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Aug 6, 2018	Rejection	Graduate student	35 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Aug 6, 2018 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 35 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Apr 5, 2010	Revise and resubmit	Non-tenure track faculty	9 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 5, 2010 Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity - Response time 9 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)	Rejection	Tenured faculty	9 months	-
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data) Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenured faculty Gender Female Race/ethnicity - Response time 9 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
May 17, 2023	Revise and resubmit Acceptance	Graduate student	6.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted May 17, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Acceptance Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity Hispanic/Latina/Latino Response time 6.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter
Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)	Revise and resubmit Acceptance	Tenured faculty	6 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data) Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Acceptance Professional status Tenured faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 6 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jun 4, 2010	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	6 months	-
Journal Analysis Submitted Jun 4, 2010 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender Female Race/ethnicity - Response time 6 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Mar 13, 2021	Rejection	Tenured faculty	6 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Mar 13, 2021 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenured faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 6 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Apr 18, 2016	Revise and resubmit Acceptance	Graduate student	6 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 18, 2016 Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Acceptance Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 6 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Mar 1, 2019	Revise and resubmit Rejection	Tenured faculty	6 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Mar 1, 2019 Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Rejection Professional status Tenured faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 6 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 3 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Sep 5, 2018	Rejection	Tenured faculty	5.7 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Sep 5, 2018 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenured faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 5.7 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Apr 24, 2023	Rejection	Graduate student	5.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 24, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 5.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Nov 13, 2020	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Nov 13, 2020 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Nov 15, 2014	Rejection	Graduate student	5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Nov 15, 2014 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity - Response time 5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Apr 26, 2016	Rejection	Graduate student	5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 26, 2016 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity Hispanic/Latina/Latino White Response time 5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)	Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data) Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender Female Race/ethnicity non-native English speaker Response time 5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)	Rejection	Graduate student	5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data) Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jan 20, 2015	Rejection	Graduate student	5 months	-	-
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 20, 2015 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors - Comments from submitter -
Mar 20, 2023	Rejection	Tenured faculty	5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Mar 20, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenured faculty Gender Female Race/ethnicity White Response time 5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jun 19, 2020	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jun 19, 2020 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender Female Race/ethnicity White Response time 5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)	Rejection	Graduate student	4.8 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data) Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 4.8 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
May 17, 2018	Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	4.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted May 17, 2018 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 4.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jul 23, 2018	Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	4 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jul 23, 2018 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 4 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Apr 22, 2019	Acceptance	Graduate student	4 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 22, 2019 Submitted by - Verdict Acceptance Professional status Graduate student Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 4 months Publication time 1 month Date of acceptance Jun 30, 2018 Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Dec 4, 2018	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	4 months		-
Journal Analysis Submitted Dec 4, 2018 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender Female Race/ethnicity Asian Response time 4 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors - Comments from submitter -
Apr 27, 2019	Rejection	Graduate student	4 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 27, 2019 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender - Race/ethnicity Asian Response time 4 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter
Feb 10, 2016	Rejection	Graduate student	4 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Feb 10, 2016 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity - Response time 4 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Aug 13, 2022	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	3.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Aug 13, 2022 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 3.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter You don't need 3.5 months to read a four-page paper, do you?
Nov 29, 2018	Rejection	Graduate student	3.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Nov 29, 2018 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 3.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter Extremely unhelpful and uncharitable comments. Reviewer's recommendation was 2 months overdue despite repeated reminders from editor/editorial staff. Why the journal would not just seek a new reviewer after the reviewer failed to submit their review within 2 weeks or so of the initial deadline is a mystery to me, and would have saved everyone a headache.
Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)	Revise and resubmit Acceptance	Tenure track faculty	3.3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data) Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Acceptance Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 3.3 months Publication time 1.1 months Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Dec 4, 2018	Rejection	Tenured faculty	3.3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Dec 4, 2018 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenured faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 3.3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Dec 12, 2022	Revise and resubmit Rejection	Graduate student	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Dec 12, 2022 Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity Asian Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Sep 2, 2022	Rejection	Other	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Sep 2, 2022 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Other Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter
Jan 26, 2013	Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	3 months	-
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 26, 2013 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity - Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jul 3, 2020	Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jul 3, 2020 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jan 22, 2022	Rejection	Tenured faculty	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 22, 2022 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenured faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Oct 4, 2022	Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Oct 4, 2022 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Feb 28, 2022	Rejection	Tenured faculty	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Feb 28, 2022 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenured faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 1 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter Given that the report is very straightforward, I don't understand why the editor still took very long to make the decision.
Feb 9, 2024	Revise and resubmit Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Feb 9, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Sep 18, 2019	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Sep 18, 2019 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender Female Race/ethnicity White Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 3 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Nov 29, 2018	Acceptance	Tenured faculty	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Nov 29, 2018 Submitted by - Verdict Acceptance Professional status Tenured faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 3 months Publication time 2 months Date of acceptance Jun 4, 2018 Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter
Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)	Revise and resubmit Acceptance	Tenure track faculty	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data) Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Acceptance Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 3 months Publication time 1 month Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Sep 28, 2009	Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	3 months	-
Journal Analysis Submitted Sep 28, 2009 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender Male Race/ethnicity - Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality - Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jan 10, 2024	Revise and resubmit Acceptance	Other	3 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 10, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Acceptance Professional status Other Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 3 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 2 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Mar 4, 2024	Rejection	Graduate student	2.8 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Mar 4, 2024 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity Asian Response time 2.8 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Apr 8, 2023	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	2.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 8, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 2.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 3 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Apr 29, 2016	Revise and resubmit Acceptance	Graduate student	2.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Apr 29, 2016 Submitted by - Verdict Revise and resubmit Acceptance Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 2.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Feb 16, 2023	Rejection	Non-tenure track faculty	2.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Feb 16, 2023 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Non-tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 2.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers 3 Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jul 12, 2022	Rejection	Tenure track faculty	2.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jul 12, 2022 Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Tenure track faculty Gender - Race/ethnicity - Response time 2.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -
Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)	Rejection	Graduate student	2.5 months
Journal Analysis Submitted Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data) Submitted by - Verdict Rejection Professional status Graduate student Gender Male Race/ethnicity White Response time 2.5 months Publication time - Date of acceptance - Number of reviewers - Comment quality Experience with editors Comments from submitter -