| Journal | Verdict | Response time | Comment quality | Experience with editors | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 22, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 22, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.2 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 22, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 21, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Conditional acceptance  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 21, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Conditional acceptance  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 21, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                3 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 21, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 21, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 21, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 21, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 21, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 20, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Independent scholar 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2.2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 20, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      2.2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1.2 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 20, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1.2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 20, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                5.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 20, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      5.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 20, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 20, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.7 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 20, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.7 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Withdraw 
               | 
            
               
                48 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 19, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Withdraw 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      48 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      In 2017 I submitted an article to Research in Phenomenology for review, and after almost a year of waiting for my submission to be reviewed or even sent to a reviewer (the status for the submission in the journal's submission portal indicated that this had not yet occurred), I emailed the journal's editor to ask for an update, but never received a response. Over the next few years I periodically sent the editor other emails, asking, similarly, for an update, but these were never answered either. After four years I finally sent an email informing the editor of my intent to withdraw my submission (the journal's submission portal does not allow one to do this oneself), and yet I never received a response to this email either. A few months after this attempt to withdraw my article, I checked the journal's submission portal once more and discovered that the status for my submission had been changed, and that my article had now been sent to reviewers, which led me to email the editor again reiterating, with growing panic now, that I had withdrawn the submission, for by this point I had submitted the article elsewhere. Like all of my other emails, this email was never answered, although my submission was finally deleted a few days after I sent this email.
All in all, I have never been dealt with in such an inappropriate manner in an academic venue. I will obviously never submit another article to this journal and in fact I no longer will read any of its publications due to the unconscionable practices if the journal. I also recommend that others avoid this journal, and particularly, that they never submit an article for review to it, unless they do not mind waiting years without a response to their submission.
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 19, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 18, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 18, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                7 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 18, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      7 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.3 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                4.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Withdraw 
               | 
            
               
                2.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Withdraw 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                6 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      6 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      Jan 6, 2020
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                8 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian 
    
      Response time
     
    
      8 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                28 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      28 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      Nov 1, 2015
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      14 months
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      Dec 1, 2016
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                6 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      6 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      18 months
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      Jul 1, 2019
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      18 months
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      Apr 1, 2007
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                6 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      6 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      3 months
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      Aug 7, 2019
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      3
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 17, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Feb 16, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||