| Journal | Verdict | Response time | Comment quality | Experience with editors | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 30, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 30, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      2.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 30, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 29, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 28, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1.3 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 28, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      1.3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit   
               | 
            
               
                4.8 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 27, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit   
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      4.8 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                7 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 27, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      7 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                7 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 24, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      7 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                7.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 20, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      7.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 20, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 18, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 17, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 16, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      10 months
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                6 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 14, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      6 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                6 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 14, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Other 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      6 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 14, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 13, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 13, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 10, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      0 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                7 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 10, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      7 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 10, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Conditional acceptance  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 9, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Conditional acceptance  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 9, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 8, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      0.5 months
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                3.3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 8, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      3.3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.8 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 7, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      0.8 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 6, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Other 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 5, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 5, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                8 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 4, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      8 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 2, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Other 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 1, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Dec 1, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Withdraw 
               | 
            
               
                8.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 30, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Withdraw 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      8.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 27, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      1.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                1.3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 25, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1.3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      12.3 months
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 25, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Conditional acceptance  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                2.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 25, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Conditional acceptance  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                4.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 24, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      4.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 24, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      0.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                2.4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 23, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2.4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      14 months
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 23, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.8 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 23, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      0.8 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                5.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 22, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      5.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                3.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 22, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      3.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 22, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 22, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 22, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Nov 20, 2011
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||