| Journal | Verdict | Response time | Comment quality | Experience with editors | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revise and resubmit  Acceptance | 
                7 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      7 months
     
      Publication time
     
      9 months
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                7 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      7 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                1.8 months
               | 
                -
               | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      1.8 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                2 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      2 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Revise and resubmit  Acceptance | 
                6 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      6 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Revise and resubmit  Acceptance | 
                6 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Tenured faculty 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      6 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                5 months
               | 
                -
               |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     Male 
      Race/ethnicity
     White 
      Response time
     
      5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                0.3 months
               | 
                -
               |  | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Non-tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      0.3 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                2 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Graduate student 
      Gender
     Male 
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      2 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                2.8 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Graduate student 
      Gender
     Male 
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      2.8 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                5.1 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      5.1 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Revise and resubmit  Acceptance | 
                5 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      9 months
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Acceptance | 
                5 months
               | 
                -
               | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      6 months
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                0.5 months
               | 
                -
               | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      0.5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                2 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      2 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                0.5 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      0.5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Conditional acceptance  Acceptance | 
                3 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Conditional acceptance  Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     Female 
      Race/ethnicity
     White 
      Response time
     
      3 months
     
      Publication time
     
      2 months
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                1.8 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Graduate student 
      Gender
     Male 
      Race/ethnicity
     White 
      Response time
     
      1.8 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                2 months
               | 
                -
               | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Non-tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      2 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Revise and resubmit  Acceptance | 
                2 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Non-tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     Male 
      Race/ethnicity
     White 
      Response time
     
      2 months
     
      Publication time
     
      3 months
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                2 months
               | 
                -
               |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Graduate student 
      Gender
     Male 
      Race/ethnicity
     White 
      Response time
     
      2 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                0.3 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     Male 
      Race/ethnicity
     White 
      Response time
     
      0.3 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Revise and resubmit  Rejection | 
                9 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      9 months
     
      Publication time
     
      15 months
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                25 months
               | 
                -
               | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      25 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Acceptance | 
                5 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                3 months
               | 
                -
               | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      3 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                0.5 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      0.5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Acceptance | 
                2 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     Male 
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      2 months
     
      Publication time
     
      3 months
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                0.1 months
               | 
                -
               |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     Male 
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      0.1 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Acceptance | 
                2.5 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Non-tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      2.5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                5 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Non-tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     Female 
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                36 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     Female 
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      36 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                1 month
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Non-tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      1 month
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Revise and resubmit  Acceptance | 
                5 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                13 months
               | 
                -
               | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      13 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                2.5 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      2.5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Conditional acceptance  Acceptance | 
                3.7 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Conditional acceptance  Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      3.7 months
     
      Publication time
     
      9 months
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                0.5 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      0.5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                5 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Non-tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     Female 
      Race/ethnicity
     
      non-native English speaker
     
      Response time
     
      5 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Revise and resubmit  Acceptance | 
                4 months
               |  |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Non-tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      4 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                3 months
               | 
                -
               |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Non-tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      3 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                1 month
               | 
                -
               |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Graduate student 
      Gender
     Female 
      Race/ethnicity
     Asian 
      Response time
     
      1 month
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                1 month
               | 
                -
               | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      1 month
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                0.3 months
               | 
                -
               |  | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Non-tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      0.3 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                10 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      10 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                14 months
               | 
                -
               | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      14 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                2 months
               | 
                -
               | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      2 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Acceptance | 
                2 months
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      2 months
     
      Publication time
     
      24 months
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Revise and resubmit  Acceptance | 
                1 month
               |  | 
                -
               | ||
| 
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
      Professional status
     Other 
      Gender
     
      -
     
      Race/ethnicity
     
      -
     
      Response time
     
      1 month
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      Experience with editors
     
      -
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||
| Rejection | 
                6 months
               | 
                -
               |  | ||
| 
      Journal
     
      Submitted
     
      Jan 1, 2009 (This date is estimated due to lack of submission data)
     
      Submitted by
     
      -
     
      Verdict
     Rejection 
      Professional status
     Non-tenure track faculty 
      Gender
     Female 
      Race/ethnicity
     
      non native English speaker
     
      Response time
     
      6 months
     
      Publication time
     
      -
     
      Date of acceptance
     
      -
     
      Number of reviewers
     
      -
     
      Comment quality
     
      -
     
      Experience with editors
     
      Comments from submitter
     
      -
     | |||||