| Journal | Verdict | Response time | Comment quality | Experience with editors | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Sep 6, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Sep 6, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Conditional acceptance  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Sep 6, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Conditional acceptance  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Sep 6, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Sep 6, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                8 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Sep 6, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      8 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      3
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Sep 6, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Other race/ethnicity 
    
      Response time
     
    
      5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.7 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Sep 5, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Other race/ethnicity 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.7 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1.6 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Sep 1, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1.6 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 31, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 31, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 30, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 30, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Conditional acceptance  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 30, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Conditional acceptance  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 29, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Hispanic/Latina/Latino 
    
      Response time
     
    
      3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                12.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 29, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      12.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                10.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 29, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Middle Eastern/North African 
    
      Response time
     
    
      10.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Withdraw 
               | 
            
               
                6 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 28, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Withdraw 
    
      Professional status
     
    Other 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian 
    
      Response time
     
    
      6 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                3.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 28, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      3.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2.5 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 26, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      2.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 25, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Other 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Middle Eastern/North African 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                6 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 25, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      6 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                8 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 25, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      8 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 23, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 23, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      0.2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.8 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 22, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      0.8 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.6 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 22, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      0.6 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                9 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 20, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      9 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      The review was not unfriendly but fairly short and unhelpful. It contained a number of misunderstandings of the text and of the literature in general. For example, it attributed views to various authors that do not have support in their texts. Moreover, my submission was handled by an associate editor who has little knowledge of the field. 
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 16, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.3 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 14, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Middle Eastern/North African 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 14, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Middle Eastern/North African 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 14, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Middle Eastern/North African 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 14, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Middle Eastern/North African 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                6 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 13, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      6 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 11, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Hispanic/Latina/Latino 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                4 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 11, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Hispanic/Latina/Latino 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.8 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 11, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      0.8 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.2 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 10, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Other 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Middle Eastern/North African 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                11 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 10, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      11 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1 month
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 9, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Non-tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Asian 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1 month
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2.3 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 7, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Hispanic/Latina/Latino White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2.3 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                6 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 7, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      6 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      1
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      Why did it take so long for such a low-quality journal to reject a paper?
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                3.4 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 6, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    
      -
     
  
      Race/ethnicity
     
    
      -
     
  
      Response time
     
    
      3.4 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comments from submitter
     
     | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.2 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|   
   
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 6, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                1.5 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 4, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Graduate student 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      1.5 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 2, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 1, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                4.2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Aug 1, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    Hispanic/Latina/Latino 
    
      Response time
     
    
      4.2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      14 months
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      Apr 20, 2023
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
               | 
            
               
                2 months
               
             | 
            
               | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Jul 31, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Revise and resubmit  Acceptance 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenured faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Female 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      2 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      2
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||
| 
               Rejection 
               | 
            
               
                0.1 months
               
             | 
            
               
                -
               
             | 
            
               | 
        ||
|    
      Journal
     
    
  
      Submitted
     
    
      Jul 31, 2023
     
  
      Submitted by
     
    
      -
     
  
      Verdict
     
    Rejection 
    
      Professional status
     
    Tenure track faculty 
    
      Gender
     
    Male 
    
      Race/ethnicity
     
    White 
    
      Response time
     
    
      0.1 months
     
  
      Publication time
     
    
      -
     
  
      Date of acceptance
     
    
      -
     
  
      Number of reviewers
     
    
      -
     
  
      Comment quality
     
    
      -
     
  
      Experience with editors
     
    
      Comments from submitter
     
    
      -
     
   | 
        |||||